Before the parking lot was striped and the equipment arrived, people were already walking into the building at 200 Skokie Blvd. to ask about pancakes. "So many people walk in and ask when we're going to open," Danny Shamoon told The Record North Shore in September. "It's the greatest feeling. If it's like that now with an unfinished product, I can't imagine what it'll be like when they see cars in the parking lot."
That building is the old Baker's Square, and it now carries the Buttermilk Café name. It is the third Wilmette space in about fifteen months to go to a morning restaurant. The other two are a storefront next to the Metra station and the ground floor of a new apartment building on Green Bay Road. A burger chain and a golf-themed restaurant both tried for the Skokie Boulevard site and fell through. In each of these three spaces, a menu that ends at lunch is what moved in.
Seven Years at 200 Skokie Boulevard
The Baker's Square site is the clearest example, because so much was tried there first. Here is how The Record lays out the timeline:
- 2019. Baker's Square closes and the building sits vacant.
- 2021–22. A Murray Bros. Caddyshack restaurant is proposed for the site, and the plan is withdrawn.
- 2023–24. A McDonald's proposal goes to the Wilmette Village Board, which rejects it.
- 2025. Shamoon, a Glenview resident, buys the property and starts rehabbing it. Village trustees unanimously approve an economic incentive agreement with him.
- September 2026. Shamoon says the café is "weeks away," with rain having slowed the buildout.
The incentive agreement explains part of why this proposal got through when the earlier two did not. It allows up to $150,000 in sales-tax remittance over no more than 10 years. Under the agreement, the Village keeps the first $20,000 in sales-tax revenue, Buttermilk receives the next $30,000, and after that the revenue is split. A building that had brought in nothing since 2019 would start producing tax revenue for the Village again, beginning with the Village's own $20,000.
The building also has a lot of seating. The Record reports about 180 seats: more than 100 in the main dining room, 38 in a sun room and 16 on a patio. This will be the fifth Buttermilk and the first one run as a franchise. The chain started in Geneva in 2014 and later added Downers Grove, Naperville and Vernon Hills. The menu covers omelets, skillets, pancakes, French toast and the chain's signature biscuits, plus sandwiches, burgers and salads at lunch.
Shamoon has said directly that he knows people remember this corner. "Everyone has a sentimental attachment to this location and I don't want to bring something that is not 100% to everybody," he told The Record. He described the goal this way: "We want to be a restaurant where your kids can come in pajamas, parents are comfortable and you don't feel swindled walking out the door."
Buttermilk's locations page now lists Wilmette at 200 Skokie Blvd. with hours of 7 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., Monday through Sunday, and a phone number of (847) 728-0135.
Washington Court Changed Hands the Same Fall
About two miles east, near the train, the same thing happened on a smaller scale. Patch reported on October 26 that Sweet Moon Café had opened at 1222 Washington Court, next to the car wash and the Metra station. It took over the storefront left by Fuel Fusion, which closed in September 2025. That space was empty for about a year. The Baker's Square building was empty for seven.
Sweet Moon's first location is in Chicago's Lincoln Square and Ravenswood area. Wilmette gets its scratch-made pastries, which combine Central Asian, Eastern European and American baking traditions. Both sweet and savory pastries are baked fresh every morning, and there are vegan and vegetarian options. The Wilmette location also serves a full breakfast and lunch menu, along with coffee and smoothies. "We've been waiting for this moment for so long! And now, our doors are finally open!" the café said in an Instagram post that Patch quoted.
Sweet Moon's hours work differently from Buttermilk's. It is open Wednesday through Monday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., and closed Tuesdays. That makes it the newer of the two that is still open after a train home in the early evening, at least through 6 p.m.
Green Bay Road Got One Built Into a New Building
Egg Harbor went into a new building. In August 2025, The Record reported that Egg Harbor Cafe had opened at 707 Green Bay Road. It sits in a street-level space in Optima Verdana, the six-story, 100-unit apartment building on the northwest corner of Green Bay and Central Avenue. It was the company's 19th Illinois location, and it opened with hours of 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. daily.
The same report named the downtown morning places Egg Harbor was joining: Hotcakes on Wilmette Avenue, EvaDean's on Central Avenue, Walker Bros. Original Pancake House a short way down Green Bay Road, and Central Station Coffee and Tea. So the newest ground-floor retail space downtown went to a breakfast-and-lunch café, on a street that already had several of them.
Taken together, the three newest additions came in through three different kinds of space:
| Place | Address | What the space was before | Hours as reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buttermilk Café | 200 Skokie Blvd. | Baker's Square, vacant since 2019 | 7 a.m.–2:30 p.m., daily, per Buttermilk's locations page |
| Sweet Moon Café | 1222 Washington Court | Fuel Fusion, closed September 2025 | 8 a.m.–6 p.m., Wednesday–Monday, per Patch, October 2026 |
| Egg Harbor Cafe | 707 Green Bay Road | New ground floor at Optima Verdana | 7 a.m.–2 p.m. daily at its August 2025 opening, per The Record |
Each of these businesses is at its busiest in the morning, and two of the three close by midafternoon. That works on a busy suburban road like Skokie Boulevard and next to a train station. A long-vacant restaurant building and a storefront by the Metra are hard to fill with dinner-only concepts, and breakfast-and-lunch operators have been the ones to sign leases there. Plaza del Lago's newer shops are a separate story, which we covered in our August look at Wilmette's two downtowns.
December Mornings Move to the Golf Club and the Rink
The busiest morning calendar of the year is coming, and two Park District sites host most of it.
Breakfast with Santa at The Lawn. The Lawn Grill and the Wilmette Park District are hosting this annual event again at Wilmette Golf Club, 3900 Fairway Drive. It includes a family-style breakfast, a visit and photo with Santa, and a goodie bag. Registration has been open since November 1 and goes through The Lawn Grill this year rather than the Park District. Seatings are at 8:30, 10 and 11:30 a.m. on these dates:
- Sunday, December 6
- Saturday, December 12
- Sunday, December 13
- Saturday, December 19
The Park District's event page has the registration link. On days without Santa, The Lawn is a bar and grill in the clubhouse that is open to golfers and non-golfers alike. According to the golf club, it is open year-round, seven days a week, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Centennial Ice Rinks, 2300 Old Glenview Road. Regular public skates run Tuesday through Thursday, noon to 1:30 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday, 1 to 2:30 p.m., under the 2026–27 season schedule. Thanksgiving week has its own pattern. There is an extra public skate on Monday, November 23, from noon to 1:30 p.m. The noon session is off on Thanksgiving Day, Thursday, November 26, and the weekend sessions are off on Saturday, November 28, and Sunday, November 29. After that, three dates stand out:
- Holiday Exhibition, Sunday, December 13, 1:30–3:30 p.m. Spectators get in free, and there is no public skate that day. Details here.
- Skate with Santa, Thursday, December 24, 11 a.m.–12:30 p.m. Admission is $5 with a nonperishable food donation, and the event includes cocoa and candy canes. Details here.
- New Year's Eve Skate, Thursday, December 31, noon–1:30 p.m. Admission is $8 for students, $9 for adults and $4 for children five and under. Details here.
The last Sunday seating at The Lawn is at 11:30 a.m., and the Holiday Exhibition at Centennial starts at 1:30 p.m. the same day, so a family could do both on one Sunday. On December 24, Skate with Santa ends at 12:30 p.m., and Buttermilk's listed hours run until 2:30 p.m.
For more on the village, visit our Wilmette neighborhood page.
The Baker's Square site took seven years, two failed proposals and an incentive agreement before a new tenant moved in. If you own a vacant storefront, a mixed-use building or a hard-to-lease commercial space in Wilmette and are deciding what to do with it next, The AVE Group can help you look at your options. Schedule a free consultation.